3 key questions to consider in building ‘on-ramps’ to higher ed success A panel of thought leaders at ASU+GSV tackled issues ranging from who's to blame for failure to the rising cost of tuition May 12, 2017 By Roger Riddell Read Time Center for Educat... Article Navigating Education In a Monday morning session at the ASU+GSV Summit in Salt Lake City, a panel of thought leaders discussed how to expand access and success, particularly among low-income, first-generation and underrepresented student populations. Moderated by University Innovation Alliance Executive Director Bridget Burns, “Building On-Ramps to Higher Ed Success” saw Strada Education Network Vice President of Analytics Carlo Salerno, University of Rochester Dean of College Admission and Vice Provost for Enrollment Initiatives Jonathan Burdick, National Louis University President Nivine Megahed, and Learning House President and CEO Todd Zipper tackle issues ranging from who should take the blame for student failures to the rising cost of tuition. Below are three key takeaways. . . . It all comes down to the responsibility of any service provider to use the resources at their disposal — analytics in higher ed, for example — to ensure customers’ needs are served. . . . Is failure the student’s fault or the institution’s? Burns asked whose fault it is if a student is admitted and then they drop out, citing stats that say about half of students are being failed by their institutions. Megahed and Salerno each responded that there is responsibility on both sides. For as much talk as there is of making sure students are “college-ready,” Megahed said it’s important, too, that colleges and universities think of themselves as being “student-ready.” “If an institution is ‘student-ready,’ you can really try to address a lot of the things that happen that end up being a result of the institution not supporting the student appropriately,” Megahed said. “I think in some situations, there’s just a lot of life circumstances you cannot overcome. But my point is, as an institution, you can only control what you can control. If you control ‘student-ready’ as an institution, and you’re doing what you can to support this population, you’re gonna get a lot more students through than you’re currently getting through.” For Salerno, it all comes down to the responsibility of any service provider to use the resources at their disposal — analytics in higher ed, for example — to ensure customers’ needs are served. “We can talk about ‘failing’ institutions or are institutions failing their students, but we have to ask ourselves some basic fundamental questions,” he said. “For example, what college says, ‘You know, I want to enroll 2,000 students, and I’m going to let 50% of them drop out?’” Among the resulting issues, he said that institution then has to consider that 50% will likely leave the institution, not contribute to positive public perception of the institution, and likely would have student loans they then would not be able to pay back. Ultimately, colleges and universities should use data at their disposal to solve immediately identifiable problems while working to understand other issues that students from underserved populations might face. One example that has been pointed out before is an unexpected expense such as a sudden car repair, which can derail the path to completion as the student has to choose between working more hours to make ends meet, or continuing their education. This sort of sentiment was echoed when Salerno noted that it’s difficult to try to force institutions into accountability for achievement when people have a variety of factors that make it hard for them to be pushed through a system, adding that he could think of “100 reasons” why a person might not succeed that has nothing to do with the institution. How do we deal with students who already have some college? There are a number of issues that come up in discussions around transfer students or dropouts who return to college at other institutions. One recurring point of concern, particularly at community colleges: When a student begins at one school but completes their degree at another, their education is often still counted as incomplete at the initial school. Another point of concern is that the credits they’ve already gained at one institution, whether they’re transferring or returning to school some time after dropping out, don’t always count at the new institution, setting them back and costing them more. Zipper said that solving access and student success would require dealing with these gaps in accurate measurement. “That is an issue that, almost every time we go to a university, they’re not prepared at all to deal with transfers from other institutions or even dropouts. And that’s the bulk of the college market today.” He said that while institutions are looking at lots of data, it’s a matter of whether they’re looking at the right data. It’s likely that this issue will persist until a better commitment to tracking completion data across institutions and more clarity around transfer credits is made. The latter could potentially be solved via competency-based methods that evaluate mastery of a topic rather than completion of a specific curriculum. How do we solve high tuition? “I think we can all agree that students want lower tuition,” Zipper said, noting that it’s especially an issue for students from underserved populations who sometimes have to drop out as a result. The cost of college is a top issue when it comes to solving both access and success, particularly for low-income and first-generation students. Calling it a “runaway issue for the last several decades,” Zipper said there are a lot of tech-based solutions working toward solving it including MOOCs, competency-based programs and alternative credentialing. As the resulting conversation on the panel demonstrated, talk of tuition often quickly circles back around to outcomes and whether they can be guaranteed. One factor that outcome discussions fail to take into account is that not everyone goes into certain fields or measures career success based on their resulting income. As Salerno noted, “completion with a purpose” would be nice in a planned economy, but that’s not what the U.S. has. People choose the degrees they want, and fewer people enroll in high-demand, high-paying fields. Zipper also disagreed with the notion of a planned economy based on the federal government offering additional money for certain fields of study. But ultimately, solving the tuition problem will still require greater engagement of policymakers at the state and federal level to return funding to sustainable levels. And for many institutions, it could also require more innovative thought around programming, such as what Paul Quinn College President Michael Sorrell has done at his institution. Group 13 Group 11 Group 12 To create a PDF of the webpage, choose in opened window 'Save as PDF' option in 'Destination' select or something like that and click to save or print button. Got it Roger Riddell Editor Education Dive Learn More In the news from Strada April 8, 2021 Public Viewpoint — Alumni Perspectives: Are Student Loans Worth It? Over the past 15 years, the number of student loan recipients has increased by 51 percent and the debt associated with those loans has more than doubled. More Americans are borrowing more money to go to college Center for Educat... Article Measuring the Val... Pathways with Pur... Career Connection Completion Consumer Voice Navigating Education Value ... February 25, 2021 Public Viewpoint Takeaways: Helping Americans Get Back to Work Expert panelists discuss the value of short-term programs, employer investments, and skills-based hiring Center for Educat... Article Career Connection COVID-19 Employers Equity & Oppo... Navigating Education Nondegree ... May 26, 2020 Pandemic puts education plans in flux as Americans prefer nontraditional sources of continuing education After weeks of uncertainty, precaution, stay-at-home orders, and economic turbulence, Americans are beginning to plan for the next stage of their lives. For many, that means making decisions about whether to pursue education and training. In the eighth week of Strada’s Public Viewpoint survey centered around Americans’ attitudes during the pandemic, we gathered insights about Americans’ plans for their education and training, which groups are most likely to enroll, and who Americans are consulting for advice on their education plans. Center for Educat... Article Adult Learners COVID-19 Navigating Education Nondegree ... May 9, 2019 Intertwining Education and Career Paths Keeps Lifelong Learners Skilled and Employed In partnership with Gallup to interview more than 300,000 Americans between the ages of 18-65 about their expectations and experiences with post-high school education. Center for Educat... Article Career Connection Consumer Voice Value ... February 18, 2019 The Important Role of Minority-Serving Institutions At Strada Education Network®, we’re interested in supporting all students on their education-to-career journey and we are fortunate to have great partners in this work – partners who understand the value of engaging with students wherever they are on that journey and supporting their success. Center for Educat... Article Consumer Voice Employers Equity & Oppo... Value Engagement & ... ... January 31, 2019 Mentors Matter: Students Value Advice and Guidance from Faculty and Employers Career mentoring is more important than ever in helping learners of all ages and stages navigate pathways between education and employment. Everybody needs the support of a mentor, from young adults entering the workforce to adult learners looking to advance professionally. Having a mentor can mean the difference between seeking more education to jumpstart a new career or settling for an at-risk job soon to be automated. Center for Educat... Article Advising Career Connection Employers Navigating Education Engagement & ... ... October 21, 2018 Mentoring Matters This week, recent college graduates affirm a growing body of research: faculty-student relationships matter. At colleges and universities across the nation, professors play an important role as mentors providing both academic and career advice to their students. Center for Educat... Article Advising Career Connection Navigating Education ... September 7, 2018 America’s Employers Place Technical Skills and Work Experience Above College Rankings Important news for all students when it comes to getting a job: what you can do is more important than the ranking of the university you attended. Center for Educat... Article Career Connection Employers ... July 17, 2018 Students Are Consumers. It’s Time to Treat Them That Way. Your opinion matters. Tell us about your shopping experience. No sooner do we pay for coffee or exit an Apple Store, than we are inundated with questionnaires, surveys, or flash polls that solicit our views as consumers. Center for Educat... Article Consumer Voice February 13, 2018 Why Go to College? Student Perspectives on Higher Ed This article by Carol D’Amico originally appeared on RealClear Education. Center for Educat... Article Career Connection Completion Consumer Voice Value ... June 27, 2017 Building On-Ramps to Student Success Postsecondary training is an expensive proposition without a guaranteed payoff. To make matters worse, many students find themselves in the position of making large financial investments and never completing a degree, a near worst-case scenario that often leaves individuals with lots of debt and no credential to earn the wages needed to pay back those borrowed dollars. Center for Educat... Article Consumer Voice Navigating Education ... June 20, 2017 Strengthening CTE Opens More Pathways to Success for Students and Employers This week Congress will vote on a bill to reauthorize federal support for career and technical education (CTE). The Strengthening Career and Technical Education for the 21st Century Act (H.R. 2353) is a bipartisan effort to elevate these programs in our nation’s schools and community colleges and to better align them with in-demand, skilled jobs. Center for Educat... Article Career Connection Employers Nondegree ... June 9, 2017 Do You Regret Your College Choices? Research from Strada Education and Gallup finds 51% of Americans regret higher education decisions. Center for Educat... Article Advising Consumer Voice Navigating Education Value ... June 2, 2017 Empowering the Consumer Voice to Transform Postsecondary Education Strada Education Network is proud to partner with Gallup, the world leader in consumer insights, to launch the Education Consumer Pulse™. Center for Educat... Article Consumer Voice June 1, 2017 Second Thoughts About Higher Education Decisions "Most former college students say they would change either their major, college attended or credential pursued if they could do it all over again, survey finds." Center for Educat... Article Advising Consumer Voice Navigating Education Value ... June 1, 2017 Survey: Second-guessing Often Accompanies Degrees More than half of adults in the U.S. would change at least one aspect of their higher education experience, according to a new survey from Gallup and the Strada Education Network. Common regrets were choice of institution and major or field of study. Comparatively, relatively few regretted their degree type. Center for Educat... Article Advising Consumer Voice Navigating Education Value ... May 22, 2017 Institutions must think broader when utilizing analytics Forcing institutions into data-based accountability around achievement metrics is difficult due to a variety of factors that can make pushing students through a system difficult. Center for Educat... Article Value May 15, 2017 New data shows low-income students equally likely to thrive These students are just as capable of thriving as those from more affluent households, but institutions and policymakers must also consider that they may need more resources. Center for Educat... Article Equity & Oppo... Engagement & ... ... May 12, 2017 3 key questions to consider in building ‘on-ramps’ to higher ed success A panel of thought leaders at ASU+GSV tackled issues ranging from who's to blame for failure to the rising cost of tuition Center for Educat... Article Navigating Education February 16, 2017 The Intersection of Instruction and Outcomes What is the relationship between college instruction and student outcomes? Center for Educat... Article Navigating Education Engagement & ... ... January 27, 2017 Advancing the Higher Education Innovation Agenda Sixty years ago this October, the Soviet Union’s launch of a tiny satellite called Sputnik shocked the United States out of its complacency over the education levels of its citizens. Our nation responded with an array of innovative new policies and practices to enhance Americans’ skill levels — especially in science, math and engineering — and open the doors of higher education to millions of new students. Center for Educat... Education at Work Inside Track Roadtrip Nation Article Career Connection Consumer Voice Navigating Education ... May 20, 2015 Our Team Center for Educat... Article Completion